The bros don’t often pause to notice the seasons, so they tend to miss them a lot! For the first Christmas, Dean definitely found a gingerbread man to give Sam, and got the bitchiest bitchface in return because what can he possibly do with this giant cookie.

Good presents for Sam definitely include more journals, notebook paper, maybe some extra pencil lead. He’s always up for more supplies. And check out this picture to see Dean building his little bro an igloo! Such fun :3

Sam and Dean were caught up in a case at the time, and it went by without them noticing. It was before the events of Taken, so Sam was more relaxed at that time.

Dean did find a gingerbread man that was Sam’s size and let his brother have it. Sam had no real idea what to do with it.

They had a much happier time together when Sam’s birthday rolled around.